Killing Germs on Escalator Handrails

An example of some of the research we do in engineering. I collaborated on a small project to test how to apply antimicrobial copper coatings to the rubbery surfaces of escalator handrail materials, using a technology called “cold spray”. It’s essentially a high velocity shot of copper particles onto the surface, and my mechanical engineering colleague Prof. Jahed led the project with his expertise in this area. Getting metallic materials to permanently stick onto rubbery materials is no easy task, but this approach seemed to work pretty well. There are a lot of microscopic technical issues that need to be understood.

My other colleague, Prof. Marc Aucoin from Chemical Engineering and I helped assess the anti-viral and antibacterial efficacy of the material after coating. Basically we showed that it was pretty good and various viruses and bacteria died off at very respectable levels (over 99.99%) when exposed to the surfaces.

This was a nice collaborative project involving professors, students and other researchers from mechanical and chemical engineering, and a combination of materials science, virology and microbiology. The resulting article was published last year in the Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, and was recently picked as one of 6 “Editors Choice” articles in 2023 in that journal. Anyone can now read it without a subscription, at this link. I’m not sure where this might lead next, but it’s a small step forward in potentially reducing disease transmission in public areas.

Is the HEPA Helping?

Once the role of airborne/aerosol transmission of COVID-19 became more recognized, lots of places starting putting HEPA filter devices into offices, classrooms, and various other locations. HEPA (High Efficiency Particulate Air) filters were initially created in the 1940s to help remove radioactive materials from air in labs and manufacturing spaces (during the development of the atomic bomb). Since then they have found common use in labs, manufacturing and other spaces were fine particles need to be controlled, and this includes removal of biological pathogens from air. Generally, a HEPA filter is one that can remove at least 99.97% of 300 nm (or 0.3 micrometre) sized particles from air that travels through it.

Photo by CDC on Pexels.com

At first glance, 99.97% efficiency seems quite impressive and a good level of protection from bacteria and viruses. However, the reality is somewhat more complicated. The basic question is whether your HEPA device sitting in the room is significantly reducing pathogen exposure or not? Like many engineering questions, it depends on the context and here we will explore some of those factors.

Continue reading